Ruminating on Hurston and Their Eyes Were Watching God

It's been quite some time since my last post.  It's now quarter 2, almost Thanksgiving, and we are cruising.  As my students continue to analyze the relationship between language, identity, and culture, we have shifted from Latino/Chicano/Caribbean writers to focusing on African American writers, primarily Zora Neale Hurston and Their Eyes Were Watching God.  This is probably the third time I've read the book cover to cover, but the first time I've actually gotten to teach it.  Three years ago, I planned a unit but passed it off to a long-term sub as I headed into maternity leave.

Their Eyes Were Watching God is not the easiest book to read.  The primary challenge is the dialogue, written in southern black dialect as heard in the 1930s.  The use of dialect was (is) a controversial choice as African American writers like Richard Wright critiqued Hurston for what he believed to be stereotypical representations of African American southerners.  He felt the last thing America needed was to read about uneducated, poorly spoken black folk.  Of course, there is another side to the story.  Hurston, a highly educated and established anthropologist, viewed the southern black dialect as rich and articulate, a deeply embedded component of the culture.  Rooted in an anthropological lens, Hurston didn't view language, or, for that matter, culture, as a hierarchy. 

By approaching There Eyes Were Watching God from this context, my hope is that students will have more patience as they work through the dialogue, sounding out the dialect (it is written phonetically) and beginning to notice patterns in the grammar and pronunciation.  I've found that after a few chapters, students begin to recognize words and the reading gets easier.  Then, we can really start to appreciate the poetry of Hurston's eloquent prose, ruminating on humanity, existence, time, and love.

Here are some of my favorites:
"There are years that ask questions and years that answer."

"She didn't read books so she didn't know that she was the world and the heavens boiled down to a drop."

"She knew that God tore down the old world every evening and built a new one by sun-up.  it was wonderful to see it take form with the sun and emerge from the gray dust of its making."

"Janie saw her life like a great tree in leaf with the things suffered, things enjoyed, things done and undone.  Dawn and doom was in the branches."

My students love these lines.  (I mean, how can you not?)  These lines linger on the mysteries of the universe while also acknowledging the individual's need for hope amid the endless search for answers. Class discussions pick up right where Hurston left off.  One student quoted her grandmother, "Love is never enough." Another said, "We are more than who we are with."  And another, "Never give up an opportunity to find love."

I, for one, am grateful that Alice Walker pulled Hurston out of obscurity. Hurston's worldview remains unique- from Eatonville Florida to Barnard College to the streets of Harlem to the voodoo culture of Jamaica and Haiti.  Her writing is a reflection of her passion for deeply rooted cultural communities and the personal journey of the individual.  Further, I am grateful that perhaps a young girl saw (sees) herself in Janie, and perhaps, because she read books, she knew "she was the world and the heavens boiled down to a drop."

Writing Prompt- How we spend our days...

"How we spend our days is how we spend our lives." -Annie Dillard

Yesterday's writing prompt reminded my students and me to be mindful of the choices we make and the passage of time.  In my own writing, I reflected on the practice of reading passages about spirituality and living in my daily life.  This practice is something that I should do more often because the passages help to recenter me, emphasizing fleeting nature of time.

Many of my students wrote about how they like to be busy because they like to be productive.  Others explained how high school forces them to live in a boring way.  Comments included:

"I think about this (Dillard's quote) all the time.  I think the time spent sleeping is a waste of time."

"My whole life is structured."

"I really dislike structured time.  If I do the same thing over and over, I get claustrophobic."

"I am horrible at time management.  I waste time by doing what is unnecessary."

"I like being structured so I can be productive, but I need a little time to myself everyday."

After listening to these refrains, I wondered- What do they consider as a waste of time?  Is being productive always the preferred use of time?

I wrote:
Sometimes  it is helpful for me to purposefully schedule unstructured time.  It's like, if it is on my calendar, I use my unstructured time in a fulfilling way.  Fulfillment does not necessarily need to productive, like getting a task done; rather, fulfillment can be achieved through the act of the task itself.  Whereas, I feel productive when I complete tasks that I don't necessarily enjoy doing.

This was an interesting prompt because I think high school is a unique time in a person's life.  When I look back at my planners and journals from high school, I notice how crammed my schedule was!  I had something after school every day, events on the weekends, and tons of homework!  I honestly don't know how high schoolers do it.  That is not my life anymore.  I think after high school, time starts to spread out as individuals have more freedom to create their own schedules.

In high school, I wrote this in my journal: "My mom told me today that time moves really fast through high school and college.  And that things keep moving really fast until after you find the person you want to spend your life with and have children.  Then it slows down."

For the most part, I think she is right.

Landlines

Quote of the day: "You look exactly like my stepmom."

Wow. 

So, students are growing noticably more comfortable, and I, generally speaking, am glad for that.  Today's writing prompt asked students to reflect on a luxury that they would never want to give up.  I wrote about coffee, revealing that my two and half year old regularly requests to go to the coffee shop around the corner because he knows how obsessessed I am.  Most students chose to write about their phones.  I remarked on my longing for a return to landline culture.  How just last night I was (re)watching the season one pilot of Sex And The City and I drooled when Carrie answered her corded home phone with "Hello!  This is Carrie."  And Charlotte replied, "Hi Carrie!  It's Charlotte!"  I mean, really, that never happens anymore!

As you can see, a simple writing prompt can quickly transform the room.  This early in the year, it is a pleasure to get students talking, sharing obsessions and recommendations.  Later, the real task becomes getting students to shift gears and focus on the day's activities and learning targets.  But, for now, I view the random conversations and anecdotes as essential ingredients for building a caring and enthusiastic class community.

Sharing Is Caring

"Who is to say that robbing a people of its language is less violent than war?" -Ray Gwyn Smith

This quote is the inspiration for the first writing prompt of the year.  I ask students to reflect on its implications, the questions it raises for them, and their stance on Smith's position.  After giving them five minutes or so of silent writing time, I ask them to share.  Somehow, every year, I tend to forget that students aren't eager to share on the FIRST DAY OF SCHOOL.  It comes as a surprise to me when the room is dead silent.  I have to remind myself that I am returning to my classroom with the end of year relationships and discussions still lingering in the back of my mind, last spring's exhuberance and passionate claims haunting me.  I have to remind myself, "Don't worry, we'll get there." 

A few courageous students volunteered responses about the connection between language and identity and the role violence can play in destroying or defending one's language.  I managed to eek out a few more responses when I encouraged students to make nominations.  I figured a student was more likely to speak if the "river otter" (a stuffed beanie baby- my "spirit animal") was in their hands.  More students participated this way, but it was far from perfect system.  Many voices still went unheard. 

I wonder about this fine line between "forcing" students to share versus only hearing the perspectives from the regular student volunteers.  Teachers- any ideas or practices that you recommend?

Quote Of The Day

"Teaching is like a draft-in-process: never linear, always changing." -Regie Routman